Who Sang It: Britney or Christina?

ENTERTAINMENT

10.1K PLAYS

By: Beth Hendricks

6 Min Quiz

Image: Wiki Commons by jenniferlinneaphotography/Wiki Commons by https://www.flickr.com/photos/rhysadams/

About This Quiz

The year was 1999. You could buy a loaf of bread for $1.49, a postage stamp for 33 cents and Napster (shhh!) had just been released. SpongeBob premiered, Barbie turned 40 and we were all smitten by a new website called MySpace. It was also the beginning of a war we didn't know was coming: Britney v. Christina.

Former Mousketeer and Justin Timberlake gal pal Britney Spears released her "...Baby One More Time" album in January of that year. The project was Spears' most successful and, ultimately, one of the best-selling albums of all time. But, there was a storm brewing on the horizon by the name of Christina Aguilera (also a Mousketeer, FYI). Seven months after Spears gave us the album we didn't know we needed, Aguilera dropped her self-titled project, delivering a "Genie in a Bottle"-sized music bomb. 

Fast-forward 20 years (yes, that's 2-0) and we've ridden the Britney v. Christina roller coaster through its highs and lows. We watched as Britney endured her now-infamous 2007 meltdown. We wondered how Xtina would navigate the spotlight as she turned from teen idol to full-grown woman and dealt with marital problems. Today, though, we've seen both women make seismic comebacks, a return to some of their former '90s glory.

So, are you Team Britney or Team Christina? Think you know them both pretty well? Put your internal Shazam to the test with this list of tunes from these '90s pop princesses. Can you tell us who's "Overprotected?" Which one of these songbirds is "Hurt?" Turn up the volume on this Britney v. Christina quiz!


Which woman sang these lyrics, "Oh baby, baby, how was I supposed to know/That something wasn't right here?"

"...Baby One More Time" was the first single from Britney's first-ever album, which shared a name with the tune. This song shattered a ton of records, becoming one of the world's all-time best-selling singles.

Advertisement

One of these ladies hit it big with a song that starts, "I feel like I've been locked up tight/For a century of lonely nights." Who recorded "Genie In a Bottle?"

"Genie In a Bottle" was the first single release from Christina's first album, which shared her name. The song was her first No. 1 hit and, 20 years later, remains of the songs most closely associated with the songstress.

Advertisement

"Oops!...I Did It Again" featured a reference to the movie, "Titanic." Whose song was it?

Britney released "Oops!...I Did It Again" two years after the blockbuster movie, "Titanic," but it must have resonated with her. The bridge of the song features the singer having a conversation that mimics one from the film.

Advertisement

This singer showed her "Hurt," in a song dealing with the loss of a loved one. Who sang, "There's nothing I wouldn't do/To hear your voice again?"

Aguilera sang "Hurt," a song about losing someone you love, but she did not write it alone. Co-writer Linda Perry contributed to the song's lyrics, which were written at a time she had just lost her own father.

Advertisement

When this singer performed "I'm a Slave 4 U" at the VMAs in 2001, she did it with a snake draped around her shoulders. Who was it?

Britney came under criticism for performing with the snake, but both the song – and that stage in her career – loudly said, "I don't care." "I'm a Slave 4 U" was one of the singer's most provocative to that point.

Advertisement

Ever dealt with self-esteem issues? This singer addresses them in "Beautiful," with these lyrics: "I am beautiful/No matter what they say/Words can't bring me down." Who sang it?

Christina tackled this weighty issue in her song, "Beautiful," released in November 2002. It was a part of her album, "Stripped," and earned the singer a Grammy for "Best Female Pop Vocal Performance."

Advertisement

Do you remember which singer wrote a song called, "(You Drive Me) Crazy?"

Released in 1999 as part of Britney's "...Baby One More Time" album, "(You Drive Me) Crazy" was the third single from her debut album. The title of the song spawned a tour inspired by the same name. The Melissa Joan Hart teen comedy "Drive Me Crazy" was named after it.

Advertisement

"Toxic" won this singer her only Grammy. Who was it?

Britney sings, "You're toxic I'm slippin' under/With a taste of a poison paradise," on this track that earned Brit her singular Grammy Award. The song likens a lover to a dangerous drug that can't be resisted. We're hooked!

Advertisement

This woman teamed with P!nk, Mya and Lil' Kim for a re-do of "Lady Marmalade" for the "Moulin Rouge" soundtrack. Who was it?

Christina was one-quarter of the female singers who tackled the 1974 original, "Lady Marmalade" for the "Moulin Rouge" movie soundtrack. The song is famous for its suggestive lyrics, so it's a good thing some of them are in French.

Advertisement

The song, "Lucky," includes these lyrics, "She's so lucky, she's a star/But she cry, cry, cries in her lonely heart." Who sang it?

Britney's "Lucky" tells the story of a Hollywood star who seemingly has it all, but still isn't happy. At the time, it led many people to speculate the song was about the troubled songbird herself.

Advertisement

Hard times make strong women. That's probably why this songstress recorded "Fighter." Who sang, "'Cause it makes me that much stronger/Makes me work a little bit harder?"

This one is Xtina all the way. She recorded "Fighter" and included it on her 2002 album "Stripped." The lyrics speak of a young woman who has endured hardships and emerged stronger on the other side. We feel that!

Advertisement

"Reflection" was written for the Disney hit, "Mulan," and performed by which of these ladies?

"Reflection" was recorded by Christina and also used in "Mulan." Its lyrics, which include, "Look at me/You may think you see/Who I really am/But you'll never know me," are about longing to be on the outside who the singer really is on the inside.

Advertisement

One of these ladies sang, "Ain't no other man that can stand up next to you/Ain't no other man on the planet does what you do," about the man in her life (at the time). Who belted this one out?

Christina delivered "Ain't No Other Man" in 2006 near the start of her marriage to Jordan Bratman. While the lyrics remain the same, her marriage to Bratman didn't, ending in 2011.

Advertisement

"All I want is you (Come over here baby)" is a line from "Come On Over Baby," a release by which of these teen queens?

"Come On Over Baby" was included on Christina's debut album release in 2000. She even re-recorded the song with Spanish lyrics the same year and released it on her album, "Mi Reflejo."

Advertisement

Which of these singers delivered the lyrics, "But all of the boys and all of the girls/Are begging to if you seek Amy?"

"If U Seek Amy" was a Britney release and part of her 2008 album titled, "Circus." The title and the lyrics of the song caused some raised eyebrows because, well, if you pronounce them just right, they lend themselves to a NSFW phrase. You might want to Google it from the privacy of your own home.

Advertisement

Madonna, who helped write "Me Against the Music," sings the bridge of the song released by which of these songstresses?

Remember that Britney/Madonna kiss at the VMAs in 2003? The backstory might have been this song, which the women performed together. Madonna was a contributing writer on this piece as well.

Advertisement

Who sang, "What a girl wants, what a girl needs/Whatever makes me happy and sets you free?"

"What a Girl Wants" is one of Christina's most recognizable tunes to date, a song with both pop and R&B vibes that hit No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart. Fun fact: The song was originally going to be titled, "What a Girl Needs."

Advertisement

Who delivered these lyrics for the ballad "The Voice Within": "When there's no one else, look inside yourself/Like your oldest friend, just trust the voice within?"

"The Voice" star, Christina, appropriately released a song titled, "The Voice Within," years before she'd ever appear on the popular televised singing competition. The song's content deals with finding inner strength.

Advertisement

Originally recorded by R&B group All-4-One, this songbird re-released it in 2000, singing, "For a shield from the storm, for a friend for a love to keep me safe and warm, I turn to you." Which gal was it?

"I Turn to You" was originally recorded by All-4-One and released in 1997. Three years later, it got the Xtina treatment, released on her self-titled debut album. Maybe you should listen to both versions and pick a fave.

Advertisement

She was "Dirrty," or at least the song was. Who released this title?

Christina's "Dirrty," which announced, "Too dirty to clean my act up," was the first single from her 2002 album, "Stripped." Christina took her image to another level with both this song and the album as a whole.

Advertisement

If you aren't empowered by these lyrics, "But now I'm/Stronger than yesterday/Now it's nothing but my way," this singer would surely be disappointed. Who sang them?

Britney's song of self-empowerment, "Stronger," was part of her 2000 album, "Oops!...I Did it Again!" The lyrics tell the story of a woman fed up with her man, stating, "I'm not your property as from today, baby." Message received.

Advertisement

The song, "Say Something," wasn't this singer's original hit, but a version with her vocals made it more popular. Who contributed to it?

Duo "A Great Big World" recorded "Say Something" on its own before bringing Christina in on the project, and it's a good thing. The song enjoyed only moderate success until Xtina's vocals made it a hit.

Advertisement

One of our singers contributed this ode to the "Candyman": "A sweet talkin' sugar-coated candy man." Who was it?

"Candyman" appeared on Christina's "Back to Basics" album released in 2006. Christina earned a Grammy nod for the single release of the song in the "Best Female Pop Vocal Performance" category.

Advertisement

Kesha contributed to the song, "Till the World Ends," which was recorded by which one of these women?

With Kesha's help, Britney took on "Till the World Ends," a project that was included on 2011's "Femme Fatale" album. A remix even included Kesha, along with rapper Nicki Minaj, lending their vocals.

Advertisement

In her first country song, this singer crooned, "I had my heart set on you/But nothing else hurts like you do." Who sang it alongside Blake Shelton?

Call it a byproduct of working together on "The Voice"; Christina and her fellow judge Blake were bound to collab on something. What they gave us was "Just a Fool," which starts with, "Another shot of whiskey please bartender/Keep it coming til I don't remember at all."

Advertisement

The gal behind this song released it not once, but twice. Who sang "Radar," with these lyrics, "Confidence is a must/Cockiness is a plus/Edginess is a rush?"

Britney must've loved "Radar" a lot since she released it not once, but twice. It appeared on her albums, "Blackout," and later, "Circus." Brit reportedly recorded this song for the first time right after filing for divorce from her then-husband Kevin Federline.

Advertisement

"Downtown where my posse's at/(Because I got) nine lives like a kitty cat/(You wanna roll, that's how I roll)" are the lyrics from a song by which of these stars?

Britney recorded "How I Roll" as part of her "Femme Fatale" album released in 2011. The song was meant to be a playful pop song and it draws comparisons to another musical diva, Janet Jackson.

Advertisement

Her "Overprotected" made it to the soundtrack of "Hotel Transylvania" in 2012. Who sang it?

In "Overprotected," Britney sings, "Say hello to the girl that I am/You're going to have to see through my perspective/I need to make mistakes just to learn who I am/And I don't want to be so damn protected."

Advertisement

Peter, Paul and Mary get a shoutout in "3," performed by which of these singers?

Britney's "3," part of one of her "Greatest Hits" albums, does indeed reference the singing group, Peter, Paul and Mary, but the entire song is a reference to a physical encounter involving more than two: "One, two, three/Not only you and me."

Advertisement

"Piece of Me" by this singer was a clapback to the media scrutiny she endured in the mid-2000s. Who is it attributed to?

While both women have endured their fair share of the spotlight's glare, "Piece of Me" was a song Britney released on 2007's "Blackout," in response to the scrutiny she was enduring. The lyrics, "Well get in line with the paparazzi," are pretty telling.

Advertisement

Singer Sia contributed to these lyrics, "I am done/Smoking gun/We've lost it all/The love is gone," in "You Lost Me," for which of these fellow musicians?

Christina tapped into Sia's songwriting capabilities for "You Lost Me," remarking that the two women were fans of one another. "You Lost Me" appeared on Christina's 2010 album, "Bionic."

Advertisement

Who sang, "I came here tonight to get you out of my mind/I'm gonna take what I find" in "Your Body?"

Christina's "Your Body" was quite a provocative song, but perhaps not AS provocative as the video for the tune, which featured the singer seducing men and then killing them afterward. Well, alrighty then.

Advertisement

In "(I've Just Begun) Having My Fun," this songstress reminisces on a party from four years earlier. Who is this song attributed to?

"(I've Just Begun) Having My Fun," is an ode to a party from four years earlier (must've been quite a party). Part of the song's lyrics say, "Here is a little story that I made up/So let's make believe/Four years ago I had a party/That was too much fun for me."

Advertisement

This singer wrote the music for "Everytime" herself and collaborated on the lyrics. Who does the song belong to?

Britney was intimately involved in both the lyrics and music for "Everytime." Some of the song's lyrics say, "Notice me/Take my hand/Why are we/Strangers when/Our love is strong," written a short time after Britney and beau Justin Timberlake called it quits.

Advertisement

This singer told us, "Lately I've been stuck imagining/What I wanna do and what I really think," in the song "I Wanna Go." Who does it belong to?

Britney's "I Wanna Go" was the third single from her "Femme Fatale" album in 2011. Fans helped choose it, thanks to a poll shared on Britney's official website. The single reached Top 10 status.

Advertisement

Explore More Quizzes

About HowStuffWorks Play

How much do you know about dinosaurs? What is an octane rating? And how do you use a proper noun? Lucky for you, HowStuffWorks Play is here to help. Our award-winning website offers reliable, easy-to-understand explanations about how the world works. From fun quizzes that bring joy to your day, to compelling photography and fascinating lists, HowStuffWorks Play offers something for everyone. Sometimes we explain how stuff works, other times, we ask you, but we’re always exploring in the name of fun! Because learning is fun, so stick with us!